By Hon (Amb) Stanford Arinze Nwokedi, JP
For about seven years now, a dangerous half-truth has been sold to unsuspecting Nigerians. Concerted efforts have been made to correct this mischief. Unfortunately, for having a political trapping, the propaganda has stuck especially amongst those who do not want to engage conscientiously.
The mischief is the incredible claim that the Supreme Court took Dist Senator Hope Uzodimma, who came 4th in an election, and made him Governor.
That story was planted politically by sore losers and, unfortunately, it stuck despite all efforts to correct the falsehood. Though politically sweet to the camp of the losers, the narrative is legally false.
In this media intervention, I intend to set the record straight and engage with my respondents conscientiously.
Using Google search, it can be seen that the case under review is SC.1462/2019 - Hope Uzodimma/APC versus Rt. Hon. Emeka Ihedioha/PDP and INEC.
Judgment was delivered in the case by the Supreme Court on January 14, 2020 by a 7-man panel led by Chief Justice Tanko Muhammad, with the lead judgment written by Hon. Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, JSC.
On March 9, 2019, INEC had declared Emeka Ihedioha winner with 273,404 votes. Uche Nwosu came second, Ifeanyi Araraume third, and Hope Uzodimma fourth with 96,458 votes.
Uzodimma's complaint to the Election Petition Tribunal was not that Ihedioha did not score those votes. His complaint was that his own (Uzodimma's) votes in 388 Polling Units were not collated at all. He said his party agents were given Forms EC8A at the polling units, but INEC staff at the Ward and Local Government collation centres refused to collate the votes from those 388 polling units where his votes were specially massive.
To prove this, he did what the Electoral Act demands. He pleaded the 388 Polling Units one by one in his petition. He front-loaded all the 388 Forms EC8A, which are the original result sheets from the polling units. He also front-loaded Forms EC8B, EC8C, EC8D and EC8E, which are the summary sheets, and he called 54 witnesses, including polling unit agents and DCP Rabiu Hussein who produced INEC documents.
Both the Tribunal and the Court of Appeal dismissed Uzodimma's petition on two technical grounds.
First, they said the EC8A duplicates were not certified by INEC. Second, they said he dumped documents without calling 388 witnesses from the 388 polling units.
Both grounds were errors of law which the Supreme Court corrected.
The Supreme Court did three things. On evidence, it held that Form EC8A is the primary evidence of an election. By Section 137 of the Electoral Act, the duplicate copy given to a party agent at the polling unit immediately after counting is admissible. Being competent on its own, it does not need to be certified again by INEC.
The polling unit is the root of the election. The Supreme Court said the Tribunal was wrong to expunge the 388 EC8As, a position which neither Emeka Ihedioha, his party, the PDP, nor even INEC disputed at trial. They allowed the entire 388 EC8As to be filed without any objections.
It was instructive to the Supreme Court that the results from the 388 polling units were conspicuously not collated in the total tally used to declare the result ab initio. That amounted to disenfranchising the electorates in those 388 polling units.
On dumping, the Court of Appeal said Uzodimma dumped documents. The Supreme Court said no. Dumping means you just throw documents at the court without linking them to your pleadings. Uzodimma did not dump. He listed the documents in his petition, tied each EC8A to a specific polling unit, and his witnesses spoke to them. That is proper pleading and leading of evidence. The Supreme Court held that you do not need 388 witnesses for 388 units; 54 competent witnesses who coordinated the agents were sufficient.
On arithmetics, once the Supreme Court accepted the 388 EC8As as valid, the calculation was simple. Just addition. Uzodimma's originally declared 96,458 votes plus 213,695 votes from the 388 units became 309,753, while Ihedioha remained at 273,404.
By Section 179(2) of the Constitution, the person with the majority of lawful votes wins. 309,753 is greater than 273,404. Therefore, the 4th position was not the true reflection of lawful votes. The true lawful votes placed Uzodimma first.
In normal electoral jurisprudence, you do not retain a false position simply because INEC announced it. You restore the lawful votes.
Note very carefully that INEC did not dispute the votes on the excluded result sheets from the 388 polling units and could not provide alternative results for those units. PDP and Emeka Ihedioha also could not tender another set of results for the 388 polling units. They could not present contrary set of Forms EC8As for the 388 Polling Units.
Four pieces of propaganda have been used to deceive the public. These must be resolved through conscientious, constructive and objective engagement.
The first propaganda asks how 4th can become 1st, that it is illogical.
In electoral jurisprudence which we all watch in open courts, position does not matter; lawful votes matter. If someone's 200,000 lawful votes are unlawfully excluded and he proves it, he will be moved from even the 100th position to 1st if his reviewed tally is the highest. It is not the business of the court to protect an illegal declaration. The court is mandated to correct all errors legally established, in the spirit of justice.
The second propaganda claims that the added votes were more than accredited voters. This was never proved. Under the Electoral Act, to prove over-voting, you must plead it unit by unit, tender the Voters Register for each unit, tender Form EC40G showing accredited voters, and show that votes cast exceeded accredited votes. Ihedioha and the PDP never pleaded over-voting for the 388 units. They never tendered any Voters Register for those units. You cannot argue over-voting in your final written address. The Supreme Court cannot manufacture evidence for you. It is not its duty to go looking for accreditation.
The third propaganda says the Supreme Court relied on an INEC server that INEC said did not exist. That is false. The judgment did not depend on a server. It depended on EC8A duplicates collected at polling units by APC agents. The mention of a server by the police witness was only corroborative, not foundational. The foundation was polling unit results.
The fourth propaganda laughably says the Supreme Court refused to correct itself on review. On March 3, 2020, Ihedioha asked the Supreme Court to review its judgment and alleged fraud.
The Supreme Court dismissed the Ihedioha Review application by 6-1. The law is settled. The Supreme Court declared itself functus officio; it cannot sit on appeal over its own final judgment. It can only correct a clerical error or where it had no jurisdiction at all. Fraud must be proved with fresh, compelling evidence that the court itself was deceived, not that you merely disagree with figures. The review did not meet that threshold. Justice Chima Centus Nweze's dissent was not the judgment of the court; the majority decision is the final judgment.
In conclusion, the January 14, 2020 judgment is a locus classicus for one principle that protects every Nigerian voter: that votes cast at the polling unit cannot be cancelled at the collation centre without reason, and if they are unlawfully excluded, the court has a duty to restore them.
You may not like Gov Hope Uzodimma politically, but you cannot fault the law in that judgment. The polling unit is supreme. That is what the Supreme Court protected.
I have now conscientiously, constructively and objectively presented the true position of the case under review, and I humbly invite conscientious, constructive and objective issue-based engagements.



0 Comments