By Hon (Amb) Stanford Arinze Nwokedi, JP
Aliyu Jaafar Aliyu writes with passion and poetry, but without an understanding of public finance under a reform government. His piece, "Nigeria's Budgets Are Corruption Manuals ..." is not an analysis of scholarly acclaim. It is a concocted media propaganda dressed in scholarly grammar, orchestrated by an opposition that refuses to understand what subsidy removal and forex unification actually did to the Nigerian budget.
Let me enlighten him on the mischief or ignorance he exhibited without insulting him. For ignorance, when it is loud, must be answered with facts.
Before May 2023, Nigeria ran a dishonest budget. Fuel subsidy was kept off-budget, hidden, and paid through Ways and Means printing. The exchange rate was subsidised, with multiple windows, round-tripping, and arbitrage for the connected. Revenue figures were misleading because the real cost of fuel and forex subsidies was kept outside the budget.
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu removed both subsidies. That is the single most honest act in Nigerian fiscal history. After that, revenue became visible for the first time. FAAC allocations doubled. Debt service, which had consumed 97% of revenue, fell to about 45%. The budget suddenly looked bigger, not because government became more corrupt, but because money previously stolen in darkness was now brought into the light of the budget.
Aliyu sees N49.74 trillion becoming N54.99 trillion, and N58.47 trillion becoming N68.32 trillion, and shouts "padding!" A scholar would ask salient questions, to wit: what is the composition of that increase? How much is inflation adjustment after devaluation? How much is the inclusion of previously hidden subsidy liabilities? How much is statutory transfers and debt service now properly captured? He asks none of these. He simply assumes a bigger number means bigger theft. That is not scholarship. That is propaganda. I can excuse this as an act of innocuous ignorance.
Aliyu confuses padding with appropriation. Padding means inserting a figure with no work, no law, and no beneficiary. What the National Assembly did was what every legislature in a democracy would do. It exercised its constitutional power of appropriation under Sections 80 and 81 of the 1999 Constitution. The Executive proposes. The Legislature disposes. It can increase, decrease, or re-allocate.
When BudgIT says 11,122 projects worth N6.93 trillion were inserted, it did not mean the money was stolen. It meant legislators added constituency projects. Were some poorly located or poorly designed? Yes. But to call every legislative insertion corruption is to deny the legislature its constitutional role. If Aliyu wants no legislative input in a budget, he should advocate for military rule, not democracy.
And on the so-called Presidential Foreign Intervention Promotion Council, the Budget Office and the ICPC confirmed that no money was released to it. A line in a budget that receives zero release is not theft. It is an administrative error caught by the very system of vigilance Aliyu claims does not exist. In the old subsidy era, such a body would have been paid in darkness. Under President Tinubu, it was exposed and starved of funds. That is probity, not corruption.
This is where Aliyu's ignorance is most dangerous. He attacks the rollover of budgets, 2024 into 2025, 2025 into 2026, as if it is a crime. A scholar of public finance knows that overlap is a consequence of late release based on the availability of funds, and it is a mark of fiscal discipline, not indiscipline.
Under the old system, government released money it did not have, borrowed recklessly, and abandoned projects when the money ran out. That is how we got 56,000 abandoned projects. Under Tinubu's reform, government releases only what it has actually collected. When revenue falls short, capital releases are delayed. That is painful. That is why only 17.7% of the 2025 capital budget had been released by the 3rd quarter of 2025. That is why Health got N36 million out of N218 billion, Power got nothing, and Housing got N2 billion out of N100 billion. The budget proposal and implementation are functions of funds availability. If it were the old order, money would be printed or loans would have been secured to fund the proposal.
Aliyu quotes those figures as confessions of failure. In fact, they are confessions of honesty. A corrupt government would have claimed 100% release and shared the money. A reform government would say we collected this much, we released this much, we rolled over the balance to next year so the project is not abandoned. To roll over is to protect the project. To cancel it because the year ended would waste the money already spent. Overlap is not a manual for stealing. It is a mechanism for completing what was started with scarce resources.
Aliyu also attacks Tracka's finding of N962.83 billion for SUVs and empowerment projects, with 2,579 projects and only 70 with clear locations. Again, he confuses design weakness with theft. Empowerment projects, boreholes, streetlights, and ICT centres are the direct consequence of subsidy removal. When you remove subsidy, you must put cash and infrastructure directly in the hands of the people to cushion the pain. It is not perfect. Its location tracking must improve. But to call it sharing ignores economics. Under subsidy, N4 trillion went to a few importers and smugglers. Under empowerment, N947 billion is spread across 2,579 locations for ordinary Nigerians. Which is more corrupt?
Aliyu laments that local governments are absent, and that the Supreme Court judgment of 11 July 2024 on direct allocation has not been fully implemented. He is right that implementation is slow. He is wrong to blame President Tinubu. Who is resisting direct allocation? Governors. It needs to be highlighted that it was President Tinubu that took the matter to the Supreme Court and won it for the people. To blame the President who fought for autonomy is propaganda, not scholarship. People resist change. However, it is now an irrevocable legal norm that Local Government Areas in Nigeria are now autonomous. That is gradually sinking in.
On the core issues, let me be clear. The opposition has no alternative to subsidy removal. They have no alternative to forex unification. They have no plan for how to fund N68 trillion without borrowing. They only have one manual, which is "attack every budget, call every increase padding, call every delay corruption, call every rollover failure, and hope Nigerians forget that they were the ones who created the subsidy cabal and the forex cabal".
Aliyu says a smaller, honest budget that is fully executed is better than a huge, fake budget. That's correct. And that is exactly what Tinubu is doing. He releases only what is available, rolled over the rest, and refused to print money via Ways and Means to fake execution. That is the honest budget Aliyu claims to want, but he attacks it because he does not understand it.
From the foregoing, therefore, Nigeria's budgets are not corruption manuals. They are reform documents struggling under the weight of decades of rot, now being cleaned with transparency. The numbers are bigger because the lies are gone. The releases are slower because the Naira printing press is off. The overlaps exist because government refuses to abandon projects it cannot yet fund. That is not theft. That is financial probity and vigilance in accountability.
Tinubu did not promise a painless reform. He promised an honest reform. And honesty, for the first time in our budget history, is exactly what we are getting.
*Hon (Amb) Stanford Arinze Nwokedi, JP*








0 Comments